foldoy vs Proton Mail vs Tuta: a side-by-side comparison
Proton Mail and Tuta are older and have apps; foldoy never asks for a phone number and takes Monero. From their own pages as of 20 November 2026.
The short answer
Proton Mail and Tuta are older and larger, with native apps. foldoy never asks for a phone number, takes Monero directly, and encrypts subject lines between users, as Tuta does and Proton does not.
How do foldoy, Proton Mail and Tuta compare?
Proton and Tuta facts come from their own pages, foldoy's from its pricing, Terms and What we can see. Prices and plans change, so check before you decide.
| Feature | foldoy | Proton Mail | Tuta |
|---|---|---|---|
| Phone number at sign-up1, 3, 15 | Never asked | Sometimes: may ask to verify a phone number or an email address | Not required, even over Tor |
| Sign-up over a VPN or Tor1, 3, 16 | Locked until it adds funds (from $10) or is approved; can ask right away | Email or text message check more likely over Tor | Some accounts held for manual approval, often VPN or Tor; usually approved within 24 hours on working days |
| Free storage1, 2, 12 | 1 GB | 500 MB, up to 1 GB after the getting-started steps | 1 GB |
| Free sending1, 2, 12 | 5 a day, 20 from day 14 | 150 messages a day | Not stated |
| Free aliases1, 2, 12 | 1, receive only | 10 hide-my-email aliases | None |
| Cheapest paid plan1, 2, 12, 13 | foldoy+: $4 a month or $48 a year; 15 GB, 50 aliases, 1 custom domain | Mail Plus: €4.99 a month or €47.88 a year; 15 GB shared with Proton Drive, 10 addresses, 1 custom domain | Revolutionary: €3.60 a month, or €3 a month paid yearly; 20 GB, 15 extra addresses, 3 custom domains |
| Ways to pay1, 4, 14 | Monero, Bitcoin, Litecoin; cards not open yet | Card, PayPal, Apple Pay, Google Pay, Bitcoin (after sign-up), cash by post, bank transfer | Card, PayPal, bank transfer on request; Monero, Bitcoin or cash through gift cards from Proxystore |
| Subject line between users1, 5, 17 | End-to-end encrypted in the webmail | Not end-to-end encrypted | End-to-end encrypted |
| Mail from other services1, 5, 17 | Encrypted with your key on arrival, subject included | Stored with zero-access encryption | Encrypted once it reaches Tuta's servers |
| What the provider says it can see1, 6, 17 | Sender, recipients, time and size | Sender and recipients, the IP address incoming mail came from, attachment names, subject, times | Email addresses and dates |
| Post-quantum encryption1, 7, 18 | No | Optional, being rolled out since May 2026 | On every account since March 2026 |
| Apps1, 8, 15 | Webmail, which can be installed from the browser. Mail apps on every plan: Thunderbird and any app with OpenPGP, over IMAP and SMTP with app passwords and no bridge to install. Apps without OpenPGP can't open encrypted mail | Web, iOS, Android, macOS, Windows (beta), Linux; IMAP through Bridge on paid plans | Web, iOS, Android, Windows, macOS, Linux; no IMAP |
| Import from Gmail1, 9, 12 | Every plan, from Gmail or any IMAP account | Easy Switch on Free and Mail Plus, with ongoing sync from Gmail | .eml and .mbox files in the desktop app, on the Legend plan |
| Where the mail is1, 6, 15 | Arrives and leaves through a server in Oslo, Norway; mailboxes on foldoy's own server, not in Norway yet | Switzerland, Germany or Norway; Swiss company | Germany; German company |
| Started, and size1, 2, 11, 12, 20 | New; no user count published | 2014; 100M+ accounts | 2011; over 10 million users |
Sources are at the end of the page.
Where is Proton Mail stronger?
A track record since 2014 and over 100 million accounts, native apps everywhere, Bridge for desktop mail programs, more ways to pay, and ongoing sync from Gmail.
Where is Tuta stronger?
Post-quantum encryption on every account, no phone number even over Tor, more storage and domains for the price, native apps, and a track record since 2011.
Where does foldoy differ?
No phone number on any connection (how sign-up works), Monero paid straight in with no gift card (how to pay), subject lines encrypted between users, and import on the free plan, and mail apps on every plan with no bridge. Where it is weaker: it is new, with no audit yet, no app-store apps, a lower free sending limit and no post-quantum keys.
Have they been independently reviewed?
Proton publishes its app code and names audits by Securitum, SEC Consult and Schellman. Tuta publishes its app code under GPLv3 and names SySS. foldoy publishes its mail client code and has no independent audit yet.
Which one should I choose?
Proton for the most established service with apps everywhere. Tuta for post-quantum keys and a low price, without IMAP. foldoy to sign up with no phone number on any connection and pay in Monero, as a new service with the gaps above.
Sources
All read on 20 November 2026.
- foldoy: pricing, Terms, What we can see and the guides on this site
- Proton plans, prices and account count: proton.me/support/proton-plans and proton.me/mail/pricing
- Proton sign-up checks: proton.me/support/human-verification
- Proton payments: proton.me/support/payment-options and proton.me/support/pay-with-bitcoin
- Proton encryption and subject lines: proton.me/support/proton-mail-encryption-explained
- Proton metadata and data location: proton.me/mail/privacy-policy
- Proton post-quantum: proton.me/blog/introducing-post-quantum-encryption and proton.me/support/mail-post-quantum-protection
- Proton apps and IMAP: proton.me/mail/download and proton.me/mail/bridge
- Proton import: proton.me/easyswitch
- Proton open source and audits: proton.me/community/open-source, proton.me/blog/security-audit, proton.me/blog/android-client-security-model and proton.me/blog/how-proton-keeps-your-data-secure
- Proton founding: proton.me/about
- Tuta plans, storage, domains, import and user count: tuta.com/pricing
- Tuta prices: tuta.com/blog/tuta-vs-startmail
- Tuta payments: tuta.com/blog/how-to-pay-for-tuta
- Tuta sign-up, IMAP, apps and data location: tuta.com/security
- Tuta manual approval of new accounts, the question "My newly created account has been marked for manual approval": tuta.com/support
- Tuta encryption and metadata: tuta.com/encryption
- Tuta post-quantum: tuta.com/blog/post-quantum-cryptography
- Tuta open source and audit: tuta.com/open-source
- Tuta founding: tuta.com/blog/tutanota-not-a-honeypot
Sign-up asks for an address and a password, and Free costs nothing.
Create your free account